tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We are building our first leadership team Scorecard and keep debating whether a metric belongs on the company Scorecard or a departmental scorecard. What objective criteria should we use to decide if a number makes the cut for the top 5 to 15?

To earn a spot on the leadership team Scorecard, a number must pass three strict operational filters.

First is the enterprise health test. If this number drops into the red for three consecutive weeks, does it threaten the survival, payroll, client retention, or fundamental delivery of the entire business? If a red metric only inconveniences one sub-department or requires internal troubleshooting inside a single seat, it belongs on a departmental scorecard, not the leadership table.

Second is the leading predictive test. The metric must forecast downstream performance 4 to 12 weeks into the future. Cash in the bank tells you what happened last month. First-time consultations, outbound quotes sent, or billable capacity deployed tell you what cash flow will look like next quarter. If a number merely records history without predicting future operational health, leave it on the monthly financial package.

Third is total ownership by a seat on the Accountability Chart. Every number must have one specific seat owner who has full authority to fix the problem when it turns red. If the metric requires a committee to explain or resolve, you have captured a broad corporate outcome rather than a clean operational driver.

Keep the total count between 5 and 15 numbers. If your leadership team is tracking 20 metrics, you are not running by data; you are hiding operational issues behind a wall of statistical noise.

Category: Scorecards & Data

← All questions