One of our leadership team members is brilliant and hits every goal, but their arrogance makes them defensive and toxic to work with. How do we address this culture mismatch at the executive level?
A high-producing executive who violates your Core Values is the single most dangerous person in your company. When you tolerate arrogance, defensiveness, or mistreatment of others simply because that person hits their Scorecard targets, you send a clear message to the entire organization that performance matters more than values. This destroys team trust and drives your best cultural fits out the door.
In EOS terms, this individual is a Wrong Person in the Right Seat. They have the GWC to perform the technical functions of the job, but they fail the Core Values test on the People Analyzer. Do not look the other way because their numbers are green.
Schedule a private, direct conversation. Walk them through the Accountability Chart and your Core Values. Give them concrete, behavioral examples of where their conduct failed to meet the bar, such as shutting down debate during IDS, speaking disrespectfully to peers, or refusing to take ownership of a team mistake. Avoid subjective labels like bad attitude; focus entirely on observable actions and their impact on the team.
Give them a clear 30-day window to correct the behavior. Define what acceptable behavior looks like in practice. Some brilliant performers do not realize the damage they cause and will make an active effort to adjust once confronted with clear expectations. However, if they become defensive, justify their behavior based on their production, or relapse after two weeks, you must terminate them. Keeping a brilliant jerk on your leadership table ruins your culture and caps your business value.
Category: Leadership Team