tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our business has scaled from three million to fifteen million dollars in revenue, and our longtime Controller simply lacks the capacity to run our new complex financial forecasting systems. She is a beloved core values fit. How do we navigate this right-person-wrong-seat issue without blindsiding her?

This is the classic Right Person, Wrong Seat dilemma. It is one of the hardest calls a leadership team has to make, especially when the person is a loyal, tenured employee who lives your core values every single day.

You cannot compromise the seat. If your business is targeting twenty-five million and an exit, keeping someone in a seat they cannot fulfill will drag down company performance and place unfair stress on the employee.

Navigate this transition using the People Analyzer® and honest communication:
- Separate the person from the seat. In your quarterly conversation, show genuine appreciation for their cultural alignment. Walk through the People Analyzer® together. They are plus-pluses across your core values.
- Address the GWC™ disconnect candidly. Be transparent about how the seat has evolved. They likely Get it and Want it, but the technical Capacity required for enterprise financial modeling, debt structuring, and audit compliance has outpaced their current capabilities. Often, the employee feels immense unspoken stress and will admit relief when the issue is surfaced.
- Explore a subordinate seat. Determine if there is a true seat lower on the Accountability Chart that matches their exact skillset, such as Senior Accounting Manager, reporting to an incoming CFO.
- Part ways honorably if no seat fits. If a downshifted seat does not exist or creates awkward internal dynamics, treat them with dignity. Provide generous severance, help them find a role at a smaller company where their skills are a perfect match, and preserve their legacy as a foundational contributor.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions