tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

One of our early employees is a core values superstar and currently sits on the leadership team, but the business has outgrown their capabilities and they lack the capacity to lead at our current scale. How do we address this Right Person, Wrong Seat situation without damaging team morale?

This is the classic Right Person, Wrong Seat dilemma. It is emotionally difficult because the individual is loyal, culturally aligned, and helped build the foundation of your company. However, keeping someone in a seat they cannot fulfill is unfair to the team, damaging to the business, and cruel to the individual.

When a company grows, seats expand. A leader who managed five people effectively at two million dollars in revenue often lacks the technical, strategic, or managerial capacity to lead fifty people at twenty million. Using GWC, this person Gets it and Wants it, but lacks the Capacity to do it at this scale.

Address the issue directly and without delay. Cracks at the leadership level appear as canyons to the rest of the company. Do not conduct a surprise termination. Have an honest conversation grounded strictly in the Accountability Chart and company measurables. Explain that while their cultural contribution is beyond question, the demands of the seat have changed beyond their current skillset.

Explore whether a lower-level seat exists on the Accountability Chart where they can thrive, such as an individual contributor role or specialized operational function. If they possess the humility to step into that role, make the shift openly. If their ego cannot tolerate a step down, help them transition out of the organization with dignity, generous severance, and deep respect for their past service. Do not sacrifice organizational traction to avoid an uncomfortable conversation.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions