tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We hired an experienced VP from our industry to run sales, but they are treating their team with aggressive command-and-control tactics that violate our Core Values, even though they are hitting their numbers. How do we handle a high-performing new executive who is toxic to our leadership team culture?

You are dealing with the classic entrepreneurial trap: the high-performing cultural terrorist. This is an executive who brings in revenue or solves technical problems, but leaves a trail of damaged morale, turnover, and fear in their wake.

Allowing this behavior to continue is the fastest way to destroy your credibility as a leadership team. When you tolerate an executive who openly violates your Core Values just because they hit their Scorecard numbers, you teach your entire staff that Core Values are merely decorative slogans on a wall.

Address this immediately using the People Analyzer. Rate this executive honestly against your Core Values. If they receive minuses on foundational values like humble collaboration or extreme ownership, they are below your company bar. A high performer who violates your Core Values is far more dangerous to enterprise value than an underperformer who lives your values.

Schedule a private Strike One conversation this week. Lay out specific, documented examples of their aggressive behavior. Do not debate their sales numbers. Acknowledge that their results are strong, but state unequivocally that the way they achieve those results is unacceptable in this company.

Give them thirty days to completely change their behavior. If team members continue to report intimidation, or if the executive dismisses your concerns as soft, you must remove them from the business immediately. Replacing lost revenue is simple. Rebuilding a shattered company culture and restoring trust across your leadership team takes years.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions