Our Operations Director has been with me since day one when we operated out of a garage, but as we expand to three locations, he is drowning in logistics and refuses to hold branch managers accountable. He matches our Core Values, but how do I evaluate his GWC without making him feel like I am discarding him after ten years?
Evaluating a long-tenured team member requires stripping away sentimentality while preserving personal dignity. When a company expands, seats inevitably outgrow the people who helped build them. Your job as a leader is to protect the enterprise first, because tolerating an operational mismatch puts every other employee at risk.
Start with an honest, objective GWC assessment. Does this leader Get it, Want it, and have the Capacity to do it? Getting it means having an innate, intuitive understanding of the role at its current scale. Wanting it means waking up genuinely energized to manage branch managers, enforce metrics, and resolve multi-site friction. Capacity means having the intellectual, physical, and emotional horsepower to manage modern multi-location operations.
Most long-tenured leaders get it and want it, but hit their ceiling on capacity. If they lack the capacity to operate at scale, you have a Right Person, Wrong Seat issue.
Sit down with them privately outside your Level 10 Meeting. Acknowledge their loyalty and contribution to the business, but walk through the Accountability Chart for that seat. Clearly define the five core roles required today versus five years ago. Ask them how they feel about the seat. Often, long-tenured managers are just as exhausted and relieved when you identify the mismatch.
If you have another seat on the chart that fits their unique abilities and core values, such as special projects or vendor management, move them there. If no legitimate seat exists, you must help them transition out of the business respectfully. Inventing a hollow seat just to keep someone on payroll destroys accountability across the entire organization.
Category: Accountability Chart & Seats