Our Head of People has been with us since we were ten employees, but now that we have scaled past seventy, she is clearly drowning in compliance, employee relations, and compensation design. She G and W, but lacks C. How do we transition this seat without destroying company morale?
This is one of the hardest Right Person, Right Seat calls an owner faces. An early employee has the core values, Gets it conceptually, and desperately Wants the role, but lacks the Capacity to lead the seat at your current scale.
Capacity includes the mental horsepower, emotional maturity, specialized knowledge, and physical time required to perform the five primary roles of the seat. In high-growth companies, a seat that worked at fifteen employees looks completely different at seventy-five. Loving the company and putting in sixty hours a week does not equal capacity.
You must separate the person from the seat on your Accountability Chart. Define the Head of People seat based on what the business needs to reach its three-year picture: designing market-rate compensation bands, handling complex compliance issues, and building scalable recruitment engines.
Once the ideal seat is clearly defined, have an open, compassionate conversation. Show them the seat requirements. In most cases, the individual already feels the pressure and is secretly miserable because they know they are underwater.
Offer them an alternative seat where they can thrive, such as Employee Experience Manager or Culture Coordinator, while you bring in an experienced executive for the senior seat. If they refuse to step down and demand to keep the leadership seat, you have a structural impasse. Keeping someone in a seat they cannot fulfill harms the entire team and limits your company valuation.
Category: Accountability Chart & Seats