Our leadership team rates every Level 10 Meeting an eight or nine out of politeness, even when the meeting was unfocused and produced mediocre results. How do we break this false harmony and use the meeting rating to fix facilitation defects?
A Level 10 Meeting is called a Level 10 Meeting because the ultimate objective is to achieve a consistent rating of ten out of ten from every person in the room. When team members routinely dish out eights and nines while privately grumbling that the meeting was a waste of time, they are practicing false harmony and starving the facilitator of necessary feedback.
To break this habit, enforce a strict operational rule during the Conclude segment: any rating below an eight requires the person to state the exact reason in one concise sentence. If someone rates the meeting an eight, seven, or lower, they cannot just provide a number. They must specify what prevented it from being a ten. Examples include: we started four minutes late, we allowed sidebars during the Scorecard, or we debated symptoms for twenty minutes without identifying the root cause.
Furthermore, the Integrator must actively challenge suspicious high ratings. If the team drifted off-agenda, missed their To-Do target, or yelled at each other during IDS, and someone offers a nine, the facilitator should push back directly: We failed to solve our number one priority and we ran over time on headlines; why was this a nine for you?
Meeting ratings are not a personal performance review for the Integrator. They are an audit of the room's collective discipline. When you normalize direct, critical assessments during the final five minutes, the team takes shared ownership of the pulse and facilitation improves dramatically.
Category: Level 10 Meetings