tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We are making our first true outside executive hire for a VP seat after years of running with homegrown managers. How do we prevent hiring an experienced corporate executive who looks great on paper but fails in our entrepreneurial environment?

Hiring an outside executive into an entrepreneurial business is high risk. The most common mistake is being seduced by an impressive resume from a Fortune 500 company. Corporate executives are accustomed to deep administrative support, established infrastructure, and large teams to execute their directives. In an entrepreneurial company, leaders must design the strategy and execute the work themselves.

To protect your company, use the EOS People Analyzer during every interview. Evaluate candidates brutally against your core values and the GWC framework: do they Get it, do they Want it, and do they have the Capacity to do it?

Getting it means an intuitive understanding of the role in a fast, resource-constrained environment. Want it means genuine hunger to build something from scratch rather than manage an existing empire. Capacity means possessing the mental, emotional, and physical capability to handle rapid context-shifting and direct execution.

During interviews, ignore high-level theoretical answers. Ask for specific examples of systems they personally built, workflows they personally automated, and operational crises they resolved with zero staff support. If they speak exclusively in terms of what their previous teams accomplished rather than what they personally produced, eliminate them. Your first outside executive must be a builder and a doer, not a passive overseer.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions