tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We are fielding acquisition offers from both a strategic competitor who wants to eliminate our back office and a financial sponsor who wants to keep our team intact. How do we evaluate these divergent deal structures against our real net proceeds?

Strategic buyers and financial sponsors evaluate businesses through completely different financial lenses, resulting in radically different deal structures and net proceeds at close.

A strategic buyer prices synergies. They can justify a higher headline purchase price because they intend to eliminate duplicate overhead, including your finance, human resources, IT, and administrative departments. While their valuation multiple appears superior, their structure often carries heavy friction:

- Severe integration risk: If part of the valuation is tied to post-close earnouts, your payouts depend on an integration you do not control.
- Severance and transition liabilities: Determine whether you or the buyer will fund severance packages for redundant employees.
- Extensive non-compete covenants: Expect strict, multi-year non-compete agreements across all relevant geographic markets.

A financial sponsor (private equity) prices standalone platform strength. They pay a lower enterprise value multiple but require your core operating infrastructure to remain intact:

- Rollover equity opportunity: They typically require ten to thirty percent equity rollover, offering a potential second bite of the apple when the platform recapitalizes three to seven years later.
- Team retention: Your leadership team keeps their seats, which minimizes cultural upheaval and post-close operational instability.
- Performance incentives: Leadership participates in synthetic equity pools or profits interest programs funded by the sponsor.

Evaluate both structures using a detailed net proceeds analysis that factors in closing taxes, rollover equity dilution, advisory fees, and the probability of earnout capture. Compare that net number against the core values and long-term vision defined in your V/TO.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions