tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

A private equity group is offering what looks like a premium valuation, but thirty percent of the purchase price is structured as rollover equity into their new holding company. How do we evaluate their capital stack and liquidation preferences to ensure our rollover shares actually participate in the second bite of the apple rather than sitting junior to massive preferred debt?

Rollover equity is often marketed as an exciting partnership opportunity for a second bite of the apple, but without careful structural scrutiny, it can become phantom paper. If the sponsor loads the holding company with high-interest mezzanine debt or issues themselves preferred units with compounding liquidation preferences, your common rollover units can be wiped out entirely upon the next exit, even if the enterprise value increases.

Before accepting an offer with significant rollover, you must audit the buyer's proposed capitalization table and security rights.

Insist on the following structural safeguards in the operating agreement:
- Demand unit-for-unit parity. Your equity should roll into the exact same security class as the sponsor's institutional capital, with identical voting rights, liquidation standing, and distributions. Refuse to hold common units if the sponsor is holding preferred units with guaranteed coupon returns.
- Review the leverage profile. Calculate the total debt service requirements of the combined entity. Excessive leverage drains cash flow and starves the company of growth capital, increasing the risk of default.
- Secure tag-along rights and pre-emptive rights. Tag-along rights guarantee that if the sponsor sells their controlling interest, you have the contractual right to sell your shares on the exact same terms. Pre-emptive rights protect you from predatory dilution in future capital rounds.
- Mandate basic information and audit rights so you receive quarterly financial reporting and board packages.

Treat your rollover as an active investment decision, not a passive concession to bridge a valuation gap. If the sponsor refuses equality of terms, discount their rollover paper to zero and negotiate a larger cash component or a senior seller note instead.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions