tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Private equity suitors keep proposing deal structures with thirty percent rollover equity and contingent earn-outs. How do we stress-test these deal structures during our exit runway so we do not forfeit enterprise value post-close?

When a private equity group presents an attractive headline valuation, look closely at the fine print. Headline purchase prices are frequently inflated by rollover equity requirements, contingent earn-outs, and deferred seller notes. If sixty percent of your money is tied up in post-closing performance metrics and minority stock in the buyer's holding company, you have not executed a clean exit. You have taken on a demanding new financial partner.

During your exit runway, you must establish an uncompromising baseline for what constitutes acceptable deal structure.

First, treat any earn-out as zero dollars. Earn-outs are designed by buyers to bridge valuation gaps and shift transaction risk back to the seller. Post-close, the buyer controls corporate resource allocation, overhead absorption, and strategic hiring. If they decide to reallocate marketing budgets or integrate back-office systems, your earn-out targets can be missed through no fault of your own. If you cannot live comfortably on the cash paid at close, do not sign the letter of intent.

Second, stress-test proposed rollover equity with legal and financial diligence on the sponsor. Rollover equity can generate substantial returns on a second liquidity event, but only if you are partnering with an exceptional private equity firm that historically delivers promised returns. Insist on clear visibility into the capital structure, preferred return hurdles, and minority shareholder protections so your equity cannot be diluted into oblivion.

Third, use your V/TO to establish clear financial targets well before going to market. When you know your exact net-cash-at-close requirement to achieve personal financial freedom, you can instantly reject complex, deferred deal structures that push transaction risk onto your shoulders.

Category: Exit Planning

← All questions