tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

The buyer submitted an offer that matches our headline price of twenty million dollars, but only sixty percent is cash at close while the rest is split between an earnout, a seller note, and rollover equity. How do we calculate the risk-adjusted value of this consideration mix to decide if the deal is real?

Headline price is vanity; cash at close is sanity. Buyers frequently present an impressive headline number in their Letter of Intent to win exclusivity, knowing full well that the back-end consideration is heavily discounted or unlikely to ever be paid out.

To evaluate this offer, calculate the risk-adjusted present value of every dollar outside of closing cash:

- Cash at close: This is your baseline. At sixty percent, you are receiving twelve million dollars guaranteed. Subtract transaction fees, debt payoffs, working capital adjustments, and taxes to determine your true walk-away floor.
- Seller note: This is unsecured or subordinated debt. Look at the interest rate, maturity term, and subordination terms. If the buyer senior bank debt prohibits note payments in the event of covenant breaches, your note is effectively frozen equity. Discount a subordinated note by twenty to thirty percent of its face value.
- Earnout: Unless an earnout is tied to top-line revenue that you personally control, historical data shows earnouts pay out less than half of their stated value. Operating expenses, post-close management fees, and corporate overhead allocations routinely wipe out bottom-line earnout targets. Discount any net income earnout by fifty to seventy percent.
- Rollover equity: Evaluate whether this equity is pari passu with the buyer shares or sitting behind preferred return hurdles. Treat this as speculative equity capital.

Add these discounted elements back to your closing cash. If your risk-adjusted total is only fourteen or fifteen million dollars, you do not have a twenty-million-dollar deal. Counter by demanding seventy-five to eighty percent cash at close, narrowing the earnout to gross revenue benchmarks, and securing personal guarantees on the seller note.

Category: Valuation & Deal Structure

← All questions