tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We have two department heads on our leadership team who sit silently through most of our Level 10 Meetings, only speaking when directly asked a question. How do we engage silent leaders during IDS without putting them on the defensive?

A silent leader on an executive team is an expensive liability. If someone sits at the leadership table, their brain and perspective are required, not optional. Silence during IDS usually stems from one of three causes: a dominant personality in the room sucking all the oxygen, lack of confidence in their seat on the Accountability Chart, or disengagement.

Start by diagnosing the room dynamics. If the Visionary or another vocal leader speaks first on every issue, the quiet leaders naturally shut down. The facilitator must manage the airtime. When an issue is identified, intentionally bypass the loud voices and invite the silent leaders in: Before we hear from sales, I want operations and finance to weigh in on how this root cause affects your teams.

Do not allow silent members to hide behind nods. If someone has not spoken for twenty minutes, call on them directly with open, diagnostic questions rather than closed yes-or-no checks. Ask them what risks they see that the rest of the room is ignoring.

If the behavior continues across multiple meetings, take it offline into a quarterly conversation. Review their seat on the Accountability Chart and evaluate GWC (Gets It, Wants It, Capacity to Do It). Explain clearly that active participation in IDS is a non-negotiable requirement of their role. If they lack the capacity or desire to engage in high-level problem-solving, you have the wrong person in the seat.

Category: Level 10 Meetings

← All questions