tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

During the Scorecard and Rock review, our team members cannot resist giving a long justification or defensive backstory for why a metric is off-track instead of just saying the word 'off-track.' How do we enforce the binary rule without feeling combative?

The Scorecard and Rock reviews are binary reporting pulses. A measurable is either on track or it is off track. A Rock is either on track or it is off track. There is no middle ground, and there is no room for narrative.

When leaders launch into defensive explanations during this five-minute segment, they are reacting out of fear or ego. They want to prove that they are working hard or that an external circumstance caused the failure. But explaining why a number is red during the review burns valuable time and drags the team into premature problem solving.

The facilitator must set the standard explicitly before reading the numbers. State clearly that the only acceptable answers during this review are on track, off track, or drop it down to the Issues List.

When a leader begins their explanation with phrases like, well we had a supply delay or I have been working on this all week, the facilitator must interrupt cleanly. Do not let them finish the sentence. Say, thank you, is that number on track or off track?

If the leader says off track, instruct the scribe to drop the metric onto the Issues List immediately. Reassure the owner that they will have the floor to explain the context when the item is prioritized during IDS®. This removes their anxiety about being judged without allowing their defense to hijack the agenda.

Keep the pace brisk. Reviewing fifteen Scorecard numbers and seven Rocks should take no more than five minutes total. Precision here sets the tone for the entire meeting.

Category: Level 10 Meetings

← All questions