We eliminated a major service line that made our Director of Special Accounts seat obsolete, but the person holding it is one of our best core values fits. How do we handle eliminating a seat on the Accountability Chart when the individual has done nothing wrong?
This is one of the hardest leadership calls an owner faces, but it tests whether you truly believe in putting structure before people. When a business model shifts or a legacy service line terminates, keeping an obsolete seat on the Accountability Chart out of loyalty burns cash and sets a terrible precedent for the rest of the company.
Your first move is to update the Accountability Chart to reflect the true operational needs of the business over the next six to twelve months. Strip the obsolete seat off the chart completely. Do not invent a fake advisory seat or create an artificial title just to keep someone on payroll.
Once the ideal structure is set, apply the Right Person, Right Seat framework:
- Look across the entire organization for legitimate, unassigned seats or seats held by low performers who lack core values alignment.
- Check whether this loyal team member has the GWC for any of those open seats. Because they are a proven core values fit, moving them to a seat they genuinely Get, Want, and have the Capacity to do is a major win for the business.
- If they do GWC an open seat, make the transition clean, redefine their five roles, and ensure they report to the appropriate leader on the chart.
If no legitimate seat exists, you must make the tough decision to part ways. Sit down with them, explain that the business has evolved past the need for their role, and provide a generous, dignified severance package. Treating a great person with dignity and respect protects your culture far more than keeping them trapped in an invented, meaningless seat.
Category: Accountability Chart & Seats