tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

Our leadership team wants to create a Director of Special Projects seat on our Accountability Chart for a senior executive whose current department is being phased out. Why is this a trap, and what should we do instead?

A Director of Special Projects seat is almost always a cowardly structural compromise. It is a junk-drawer box created by leadership teams who are unwilling to have a difficult conversation with an executive who no longer fits the company real needs. In an exit-ready organization, every seat on the Accountability Chart must represent an essential, recurring operational function that drives measurable business outcomes.

Creating a nebulous special projects seat creates three severe problems. First, it introduces structural ambiguity. Because the seat lacks clean boundaries, the person in it inevitably meddles in other departments, bypassing the Integrator and undermining functional seat holders. Second, it adds heavy, non-productive overhead directly to your income statement, dragging down your EBITDA margins. Third, sophisticated buyers see right through it during due diligence. They view catch-all executive titles as evidence of poor leadership discipline and owner-run nepotism.

Instead of inventing an artificial seat, run the hard process. Look at your pure forward-looking Accountability Chart. Ask whether there is a legitimate, vacant seat required by the business where this executive has total GWC and fits your core values. If there is, place them in that seat and hold them accountable to its specific roles and Scorecard metrics.

If no such seat exists, IDS the issue honestly. Give the executive a clean, respectful exit package and part ways professionally. Do not pollute your company architecture and confuse your entire organization just to avoid an uncomfortable conversation.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions