tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

One of our department leaders understands her job description and works long hours, but her department is constantly missing Scorecard measurables and Rock deadlines. How do we diagnose whether this is a GWC issue or a structural problem with her seat on the Accountability Chart?

When a committed leader consistently misses measurables, leadership teams often assume it is a personal performance failure. However, you must systematically diagnose whether the problem lives in the person or in the design of the seat.

Run the issue through this two-part diagnostic:

First, audit the seat structure on your Accountability Chart. Does the seat have more than five core roles? Is this person managing too many direct reports? Are they burdened with conflicting priorities, such as being accountable for both long-term strategic development and day-to-day firefighting? If the seat is overloaded, even an A-player will fail. Strip the seat back down to five distinct, manageable roles and rebalance department responsibilities.

Second, evaluate GWC objectively against the cleaned-up seat:

- Gets It: Do they truly understand the essence of the role, how it fits into the company, and how to solve problems without being told?
- Wants It: Do they genuinely enjoy the work, or are they grinding out seventy hours a week out of obligation, fear, or ego?
- Capacity: Do they possess the intellectual, emotional, and physical capability, as well as the available time, to excel in the seat?

Working long hours while missing deadlines is the hallmark of someone who has the desire, but lacks the Capacity to Do It. If the seat is properly structured and the leader still cannot hit their numbers during a normal work week, they are in the wrong seat. Reposition them or find someone with full GWC.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions