tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

One of our department heads scores all pluses on our core values and swears he GWCs his seat, but his weekly Scorecard numbers have been red for three consecutive quarters. How do we determine whether this is a poorly designed seat on our Accountability Chart or an honest GWC failure we have been ignoring?

Scorecard numbers do not lie, but they require accurate root-cause diagnosis. When a leader is an undeniable core values match and genuinely claims to Get, Want, and have the Capacity for his seat, but his measurables consistently miss the mark, you are facing one of three issues.

Use this diagnostic sequence to identify the truth:

- Audit the seat roles: Pull up your Accountability Chart. Does this seat have five clearly defined, realistic roles, or has it become a dumping ground for ten random tasks? If the seat is structurally overloaded, the leader may have the capacity for the core function, but is drowning under operational clutter. Redesign the seat to its five core responsibilities.
- Audit the measurable: Is the Scorecard metric an accurate reflection of what that seat directly controls? If your operations leader is held accountable for gross margin, but the sales team is discounting pricing without operational approval, the metric is broken, not the person. Ensure the metric has absolute single-point control.
- Test real Capacity: If the seat design is clean and the metric is completely fair, then the leader does not GWC the seat. Saying you want the seat and understand it conceptually is very different from having the execution capacity to deliver predictable weekly results.

Give the leader thirty days with crystal-clear Rocks and absolute role clarity. If the numbers remain red, stop rationalizing. Pluses on core values only prove he is the Right Person; chronic red measurables prove he is in the Wrong Seat. Move him or replace him.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions