tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We have a veteran team member who is a 100 percent core values fit and a beloved culture carrier, but she has failed in two different operational seats as we have grown. My team wants to keep shuffling her to a third seat, but I am worried we are just kicking the can down the road. How do you distinguish between a temporary seat mismatch and a fundamental GWC ceiling?

Keeping a great culture fit who consistently fails to perform in their seat is one of the most painful traps an owner can fall into. You love the person, they embody every core value, and they have sacrificed for the company. But having the Right Person in the Wrong Seat still costs the business dearly.

To determine whether this is a fixable seat alignment issue or a hard capacity ceiling, evaluate her against GWC™ with absolute intellectual honesty.

Does she truly Get the seat? Getting it is about natural wiring, instinct, and cognitive grasp. If you have to explain the fundamental mechanics of the job over and over, she does not get it.

Does she Want it? Does she wake up genuinely excited to own the outcomes, or is she just taking the role out of loyalty to you and a desire to remain employed?

Does she have the Capacity? Capacity includes emotional maturity, intellect, physical time, and learned skills. As businesses scale from five million to fifteen million, the capacity required to lead a department fundamentally changes. A person who managed three people brilliantly may hit a hard cognitive ceiling when managing thirty.

If you shuffle someone across multiple departments and results remain sub-par, you are not dealing with a seat mismatch. You are dealing with a capacity ceiling.

Stop inventing synthetic seats just to keep a beloved person on the payroll. Have a courageous, compassionate conversation. If there is a legitimate, lower-level seat where she genuinely GWC-s the work and adds direct value, offer it to her with an adjusted title and compensation. If no such seat exists, help her exit with dignity, severance, and gratitude.

Category: Accountability Chart & Seats

← All questions