tyler-smith.com · Questions & Answers

We just completed a small acquisition and now have two strong department heads competing for the single Operations seat on our leadership Accountability Chart. How do we choose the right person and manage the fallout with the leader who is not selected?

You cannot have two heads on one body. Putting co-directors into a single seat creates confusion, paralyzes decision-making, and splits your staff into loyalist camps. You must identify one clear leader for the Operations seat on your Accountability Chart, and you must do it quickly.

Evaluate both individuals strictly through the EOS lens: Core Values and GWC. Step back from their current titles or who has more tenure. Define the five core roles of the combined Operations seat in your forward-looking Accountability Chart. Next, evaluate both leaders. Does each person consistently reflect your Core Values? Do they Get, Want, and have the Capacity for this specific combined role? If one candidate clearly wins on Core Values and GWC, the choice is made.

If both candidates qualify, look at who has demonstrated the ability to scale systems and lead managers rather than just execute tasks. The Integrator and Visionary must make the final call without hesitation or apologies. Do not drag the decision out over months of political lobbying.

Once decided, deliver the news directly and individually. Meet with the selected candidate first to confirm their commitment and establish expectations. Immediately afterward, meet with the other leader. Be transparent about why the decision was made. If you have an open, vital seat on the Accountability Chart that leverages their unique strengths, present it with clear roles and boundaries. If no such seat exists, or if their ego cannot accept reporting to their former peer, help them transition out of the organization with dignity. Keeping a disgruntled former peer in the building will sabotage your integration.

Category: Leadership Team

← All questions