How do we audit our leadership Scorecard to ensure that our weekly targets are not driving unintended, toxic behaviors across our operational teams?
Every measurable on a Scorecard creates an incentive. When leadership establishes an aggressive metric without considering the systemic impact, employees will naturally optimize their daily work to keep their Scorecard box green, even if it harms the company.
If you track customer support tickets closed per week without measuring first-contact resolution or reopened tickets, your support staff will rush through complex problems or close unresolved tickets just to inflate their volume.
To prevent this distortion, perform a quarterly audit of your Scorecard during your offsite planning sessions. Evaluate whether any green metric is masking an operational decline elsewhere in the business.
A proven safeguard is to balance quantity metrics with quality or efficiency counterweights:
- Balance sales calls completed with discovery-to-proposal conversion rates.
- Balance billable hours logged with client satisfaction scores or project gross margins.
- Balance operational tickets resolved with ticket reopen percentages.
If an individual consistently hits their activity volume while the paired quality metric collapses, they are gaming the system. Use the IDS process in your Level 10 Meeting to examine the root cause and refine the metric definitions.
Category: Scorecards & Data