The buyer is offering our target enterprise value multiple, but their LOI specifies an asset purchase rather than a stock purchase. How does an asset sale structure erode our net walk-away cash through depreciation recapture and taxes, and how do we negotiate a gross-up?
Buyers prefer an asset sale because it allows them to step up the tax basis of your assets for future depreciation and leave behind unknown operational liabilities. However, an asset sale can trigger catastrophic tax consequences for you, effectively reducing your real purchase price by fifteen to thirty percent.
In an asset sale, your net cash is eroded through two primary mechanisms:
- Ordinary income and depreciation recapture: Proceeds allocated to depreciable tangible equipment, tooling, and inventory are taxed at ordinary income rates rather than long-term capital gains rates. Depending on your tax bracket, that distinction can mean a twenty percent swing in tax liability on those asset classes.
- Entity-level double taxation: If you operate as a C-Corporation, an asset sale creates double taxation: once at the corporate level when the company sells the assets, and again at the shareholder level when the remaining cash is distributed to you.
To protect your walk-away proceeds, take these negotiation steps before signing the LOI:
- Push for a stock sale: Insist on a stock purchase or suggest a structured equity transfer, such as a Section 338(h)(10) election, which gives the buyer tax step-up benefits while compensating you for the liability.
- Require a tax gross-up provision: If the buyer refuses a stock deal, require language in the LOI stating that the purchase price assumes a mutually agreed purchase price allocation. If an asset sale creates an incremental tax burden above a standard stock transaction, the buyer must gross up the total cash purchase price to make you whole.
Never negotiate headline enterprise value without calculating your net after-tax proceeds. The structure of the sale determines what actually lands in your bank account.
Category: Valuation & Deal Structure