The buyer's LOI specifies an asset purchase so they can write up our assets and take a step-up in tax basis, but our CPA estimates that depreciation recapture will cost us over a million dollars in net cash. How do we negotiate the transaction structure or price to offset this tax drag?
Buyers almost always prefer asset sales because Section 197 allows them to amortize acquired intangible assets over fifteen years, generating significant future tax savings while insulating them from your unknown historical liabilities. For you as the seller, an asset sale can trigger punitive depreciation recapture taxed at ordinary income rates rather than long-term capital gains.
Do not quietly absorb this tax hit. The buyer's tax benefit represents real economic value created directly by your transaction structure, and that value must be negotiated.
- Model the exact net proceeds of a stock sale versus an asset sale with your M&A tax advisor, quantifying the exact dollar gap caused by ordinary income recapture and state tax divergence.
- Propose a joint election under Internal Revenue Code Section 338(h)(10) or Section 336(e) if you are an S-corporation. This allows the buyer to treat the transaction as an asset sale for tax purposes while you execute a stock transfer for legal purposes, streamlining closing mechanics.
- Demand an explicit tax gross-up clause in the definitive agreement. If the buyer insists on an asset treatment, require them to increase the gross enterprise value by the exact difference in your tax liability, effectively sharing the present value of their future depreciation tax shield.
- Negotiate the purchase price allocation under Section 1060 aggressively. Push allocations away from heavily depreciated equipment and toward goodwill or personal goodwill, which preserves preferential capital gains treatment.
Establish these parameters at the LOI stage before granting exclusivity. Once the LOI is executed without specifying the tax allocation mechanism, your leverage to demand a purchase price adjustment evaporates.
Category: Valuation & Deal Structure